Beautiful Books: Uncle Silas

Posted July 29, 2018 by Lory in reviews / 18 Comments

J. Sheridan Le Fanu, Uncle Silas (1864)

It’s yet another classic book review! I’ve been doing a lot of these lately as I try to plow through my accumulated TBR pile. But while on vacation I took a whole bunch of newer books along with me on the e-reader, so I hope to have something completely different for you very soon. Even though I do like reviewing classics, I don’t want to focus on them exclusively on the blog.

In the meantime, I’m going back to the Victorian era with a giant of the Gothic genre. I confess that it was the looks, not the content, of this book that initially caught my attention. It’s a Folio Society edition with illustrations by Charles Stewart, a fascinating character in his own right — a theatre enthusiast, collector, and artist who was obsessed with the tale for many years. He created some of the pictures for an edition that never made it into print, but these were eventually incorporated into the Folio publication along with a gorgeous period-style binding design.

The illustrations are also beautifully in tune with the Victorian aesthetic, and though done in pen and ink imitate the engravings that often adorned books of the period. These are plentiful and add marvelously to the brooding atmosphere. The typography is unobtrusively excellent as well.

But what about the story? (Spoiler alert here — I’m going to refer to some major plot points.) It’s narrated by a seventeen-year-old girl who inherits her father’s enormous estate and is sent to live with her Uncle Silas in his crumbling house. She wants to honor her father’s wish to believe him innocent of a horrible crime of which he was accused years ago, but this becomes more and more difficult as the ominous characters and events pile up …

Though I enjoyed the book overall, I was left with a faint sense of disappointment. Many elements seemed to me to have more potential than was actually fulfilled. There was a fantastically villainous French governess, for instance, but Le Fanu seemed to lose interest in her and her evil petered out into ridiculousness. Another character, a neglected girl with a wonderfully unconventional personality and manner of  speaking, had to be immediately smoothed out and made into a model of Victorian propriety, which was unfortunate. And there was a big build-up of the “Swedenborgian” view of spirits and angels, which would seem to presage some supernatural-slash-psychological crisis, but nothing came of this.

Most seriously, our heroine, Maud, was too silly and passive for my taste. I loved the theme of trying to break through deception to the true reality, but Maud spent far too much time clinging to her wish for Silas to be good, even when it was completely obvious that he wasn’t. She ignored her forebodings for so long that she deserved what came to her, and was saved not by her own awakened initiative and insight, but by some equally silly antics on the part of her captors.

These left me baffled, because they were trying to kill Maud very cleverly in secret so that nobody would know, but the whole point of killing her was to get her inheritance, for which purpose her death would need to be made public. Perhaps this was an indication of Silas’s disturbed mental state, but as a crime it made no sense.

Then there was the way her killer had to enter the murder room laboriously through a secretly contrived window, creating a locked-room mystery — but then Silas barged in to check on the murder through the door. Wouldn’t it have been easier for the murderer to just go in through the door and exit through the window?

And so on. Such inconsistencies left me with a sense that Le Fanu was not quite in command of his material, in spite of the parts of it that shone. Influential as he was in the beginnings of the Gothic/thriller genre, there are others who have done it better — though for a dive back into those early days of the genre, you can’t do better than this beautifully rendered edition.

Classics Club list #68

Beautiful Books: Uncle SilasUncle Silas by J. Sheridan LeFanu
Published by Folio Society in 1988 (originally 1864)
Format: Hardcover from Personal Collection

Tags: , , , , ,

Divider

18 responses to “Beautiful Books: Uncle Silas

  1. I read this a few years ago and enjoyed it, but I agree that there are other books of this type that are better. Your edition is beautiful, though – much nicer than the one I read!

  2. I always find myself just a little unsatisfied with Le Fanu. I honestly can’t remember if I’ve read this one but I don’t think so. I think I’ve only read him in short story/novella form. I can see how some of the issues I had would be magnified in the novel form though!

    • If Maud had been a better heroine, it would have made all the difference. Wilkie Collins would have done a better job with her.

  3. Thank you for reading this one, so I don’t have to:). I think your gentle comment that the author isn’t fully in command of his material hits the spot…

    • Well, he sort of seemed to lose interest but had to complete the three volumes demanded at the time I suppose. There are other Victorian novels that suffer from this problem.

  4. Kat

    i have this edition and I agree that the illustrations are beautiful! I devoured this in a day and enjoyed the Gothic suspense. Of course I agree that it all sounds very silly… 🙂

  5. Such a beautiful book!

    I have to admit that you are completely right about everything in your analysis BUT despite it all, I absolutely love the book, there is something about the atmosphere of it. And I’m fond of Maud too, silly and passive as she is.

    There was a TV series made of it back in the day with Peter O’Toole as Uncle Silas, and I enjoyed that too though I suspect it may have been terrible.

    • I became fond of Maud too, but by the end she was too frustrating!! The atmosphere was masterfully built up, and I can see how it probably influenced oodles of other writers.

      Peter O’Toole would be perfect for Uncle Silas. That series could be a great guilty pleasure.

  6. I liked this book alright, but I was expecting more of a mystery and I think it is really about the psychological manipulation of Maud. I loved Millie and agree that it is a bit sad she had to be so tamed in the end.

    I was so surprised to find out that Swedenborgism was real! So I learned something from reading the book too. 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.